BlackBerry Q5
Spécifications de l'ordinateur portable
Price comparison
Moyenne de 12 notes (à partir de 18 critiques)
Critiques pour le/la BlackBerry Q5
Mesures d'austérité? Après l'exceptionnel BlackBerry Q10, le fabricant Canadien sort une version moins chère nommée BlackBerry Q5. Pour un prix de 399 Euros (~$534), ce smartphone avec un clavier QWERTY possède certains traits en commun avec la version Q10, comme le processeur Qualcomm Snapdragon S4 Plus SoC avec 1.2 GHz, 8 Go de mémoire flash et 2 Go RAM.
Source: Tech Advisor EN→FR Archive.org version
It's a mixed bag when it comes to the BlackBerry Q5. It's cheaper than both the BlackBerry Q10 and Z10 and a lot of its hardware specs are better than we expected. However, build quality isn't inspiring and while BlackBerry 10 is smooth with good features, a shortage of apps remains a downfall.
Critique simple, disponibles en ligne, Courte, Date: 08/13/2013
Notes: Note globale: 60% prix: 60% performances: 60% équipement: 60% finition: 50%
Source: Engadget EN→FR Archive.org version
The BlackBerry Q5 isn't a bad handset, but it carries the weight of disappointment when you realize that it's not just a stripped-down Q10. Had it been, we'd probably be far more appreciative of the hardware, but as it stands we have two objections we simply can't get past. First things first, the price.
Critique simple, disponibles en ligne, Longue, Date: 07/18/2013
Source: Think Digit EN→FR Archive.org version
The Q5 is a tad more expensive than what the sweet spot would have been - somewhere around the Rs. 20,000 mark. It's a must buy for those who desperately want a BlackBerry 10 device, but for whom the Q10 is out of budget. Otherwise, for the same amount of money, a few Android phones and the Apple iPhone 4 (if you don't mind the old phone) will offer better application variety and usage experience.
Critique simple, disponibles en ligne, De taille moyenne, Date: 07/17/2013
Notes: Note globale: 60% prix: 50% performances: 70% équipement: 60% finition: 70%
Source: Tech2.in.com EN→FR Archive.org version
The first piece of good news is that the Q5 is substantially cheaper than the Q10. BlackBerry has had to cut down on some key specifications and the materials used to build it, but overall you’re left with a very good experience that comes close to its more expensive brethren. However, Rs 24,990 is still quite expensive for the Q5 as we would peg the value of the handset at not more than Rs 20,000. If BlackBerry drops the price to sub-20k, then the Q5 has the potential for doing well.
Critique simple, disponibles en ligne, De taille moyenne, Date: 07/17/2013
Notes: Note globale: 60%
Source: T3 EN→FR Archive.org version
The Q5 is a tough call to make. It’s almost certainly going to become the work BlackBerry if the Z10 hasn’t already and while we commend BlackBerry’s intentions in trying to create a BB10 handset for both work and youth, it's kinda missed the point. Would we recommend it? If you’re after a typing experience but can’t afford the frankly silly price of the Q10 then this is definitely your best bet, but if you’re after something more than that we’d have to suggest looking elsewhere.
Critique simple, disponibles en ligne, Courte, Date: 07/16/2013
Notes: Note globale: 60%
Source: V3.co.uk EN→FR Archive.org version
We expected the more expensive BlackBerry Q10 to put its cheaper sibling to shame in pretty much every category. However, having compared the two, we found the two smartphones fairly evenly matched, raising the question as to whether the BlackBerry Q10 is worth the extra £200. Aside from those considerations, however, we found that the BlackBerry Q5 does a good job for its price, matching the BlackBerry Q10 with regard to screen, performance, operating system and all-round usability.
Comparaison, disponibles en ligne, De taille moyenne, Date: 07/16/2013
Source: Reg Hardware EN→FR Archive.org version
All in all, the Q5 is a workhorse with an OS still in its early days. I suspect the "ambitious" and "youthful" crowd won’t be getting a Q5 out of choice - it’s still too expensive. It needs to be on a £20/month contract to be considered, and they’ll be after something classier if they can afford it. Priced alongside last year’s Galaxy S3 for example, it’s hard to see who in that target market would opt for this drab offering. The beloved BIS, which piped email and BBM to a BlackBerry subscriber for a flat rate, is gone, and isn’t coming back. Very shortly one will no longer need to buy a BlackBerry to tap into the previously exclusive BBM social network. For enterprises, particularly those with a sunken investment in BlackBerry Enterprise Server and corporate apps, it’s a more solid choice. Shame about the unforgiving keyboard.
Critique simple, disponibles en ligne, De taille moyenne, Date: 07/10/2013
Source: It Pro EN→FR Archive.org version
With decent performance levels and a mid-range price, the Q5 is reasonable handset. However, it's suited more to the consumer market and is unlikely to anything more than a secondary messaging device for most business users due to the small screen.
Critique simple, disponibles en ligne, Courte, Date: 07/08/2013
Notes: Note globale: 60%
Source: Slashgear EN→FR Archive.org version
What gives us most pause about the Q5 is its price. It may have half the name of the Q10, but it doesn’t have half the RRP: in fact, SIM-free in the UK where sales have already begun, the Q5 is £320 ($477) including tax, versus £480 ($715) for the Q10. Sign up to a contract, and you’ll spend just £8 ($12) per month more for the Q10 than the Q5. We’d argue not only that the Q10 is still too expensive for what you get – though we’d prefer it over the Q5 – but that the Q5 isn’t as cheap as it really needs to be. If you’re determined to get a BlackBerry and must have a keyboard, then the Q10 should be your choice; everybody else will likely find more rewarding devices running Android or iOS.
Critique simple, disponibles en ligne, De taille moyenne, Date: 07/07/2013
Source: Techradar EN→FR Archive.org version
The BlackBerry Q5 is difficult to love. Sure it's got all the core smartphone features, but it doesn't really excel at anything, apart from perhaps web browsing, but even that's hampered somewhat by the pokey 3.1-inch display. The BlackBerry Q5 feels like it should be dropped down the pricing scale, towards the bottom of the mid-tier of smartphones - and at that price we could very well be recommending it, but as it stands it's hard to make a convincing argument for this BlackBerry 10 handset.
Critique simple, disponibles en ligne, Très longue, Date: 07/04/2013
Notes: Note globale: 60% prix: 50% performances: 70% équipement: 70% finition: 40%
Source: V3.co.uk EN→FR Archive.org version
Summing up, we've found the Q5 lives up to the legacy set by its top-end siblings, delivering the same BYOD and productivity services that made the Z10 and Q10 an ideal choice for business. However, it also suffers from the same weakness, featuring middling build quality, a screen overly prone to picking up glare and an average rear-facing camera. All this adds up to mean that while the Q5 is a good, semi-affordable option for businesses users eager to upgrade their existing work BlackBerry, we can't see it having any real mass market appeal.
Critique simple, disponibles en ligne, Longue, Date: 07/01/2013
Notes: Note globale: 80%
Source: T3 EN→FR Archive.org version
With two high-end devices already out it makes sense that BlackBerry would return to its established emerging markets and make a phone that would be deemed ‘affordable’. What will be most interesting however is seeing just how affordable it really is, sporting many of the same specs as the Q10 many users could be in for a shock when BlackBerry does finally release pricing information.
Critique simple, disponibles en ligne, Très courte, Date: 05/15/2013
Source: Stiftung Warentest - Heft 2/2014
Critique simple, , Longueur inconnue, Date: 01/01/2014
Notes: Note globale: 84%
Source: Stiftung Warentest - Heft 1/2014
Critique simple, , Longueur inconnue, Date: 12/01/2013
Notes: Note globale: 84% mobilité: 87%
Source: Connect - Heft 10/2013
Critique simple, , Longueur inconnue, Date: 09/01/2013
Notes: Note globale: 82%
Source: Notebookinfo DE→FR Archive.org version
Critique simple, disponibles en ligne, De taille moyenne, Date: 08/07/2013
Notes: performances: 83% écran: 100% mobilité: 95% ergonomie: 100% degré de nuisance: 90%
Source: Netzwelt DE→FR Archive.org version
Critique simple, disponibles en ligne, Longue, Date: 08/02/2013
Source: Connect - Heft 2/2014
Critique simple, , Longueur inconnue, Date: 01/01/2013
Notes: Note globale: 82%
Commentaire
Qualcomm Adreno 225:
Ses cartes graphiques ne sont pas faites pour le jeu. Et même si ils tournent, ce sera avec des erreurs d'affichage et un framerate ignoble. Ce cartes graphique sont totalement incompatible avec les joueurs! les applications de bureau et d'Internet, ne sont pas un problème pour ces cartes graphiques.
>> Plus d'informations sont à trouver dans notre comparaison des cartes graphiques mobiles et ainsi que dans notre liste des Benchmarks affiliés.
S4 Plus MSM8960: SoC Dual-Core Krait haut de gamme intégrant une puce graphique Adreno 225.
>> Plus d'informations sont à trouver dans notre comparaison des processeurs mobiles.
3.10": Il s’agit de l’une des diagonales les plus petites pour un smartphone.
Un écran de plus grandes dimensions permettent des résolutions plus élevées, les détails comme la finesse des lettres seront meilleurs. Néanmoins, un écran de plus petite taille est synonyme de consommation énergétique moindre et souvent d’un terminal plus compact, plus léger et plus abordable.
>> Pour en savoir un peu plus sur la finesse des pixels à l'écran, jetez un coup d'œil à notre liste des DPI (PPP, points par pouce).
71.58%: La note est mauvaise. La plupart des portables sont mieux notés. Nous ne conseillons pas cet achat.
>> Plus d'informations sont à trouver dans notre guide d'achat pour les ordinateurs portables.